In James v James [2026] EWHC 2190 (Ch), a mother’s 1994 Will left her estate to her two sons “as shall survive me”. One son died before her, leaving a daughter. The surviving son claimed everything.
The High Court disagreed. Under section 33 of the Wills Act 1837, a gift to a child who dies before you passes to that child’s own children — unless your Will clearly says otherwise. “As shall survive me” was not enough, and a later family falling-out made no difference.
- The rule applies automatically; you have to opt out in your Will.
- For business owners and landlords, shares or property can end up with grandchildren, sometimes young ones.
- Decide what you want, say it clearly, think about trusts for young beneficiaries, and review your Will when the family changes.
Read the full article on our website →
Get Legacy Insights free every Sunday
Six short reads each week on tax, Wills, family wealth and running a business, from John Ireland. Since 1996, three decades of protecting families.