James v James: when an old Will passes a share to a grandchild

Most people sign a Will and then, quite understandably, stop thinking about it. Life carries on. Children grow up, marry, have children of their own. Sometimes there is a death in the family, and sometimes there is a falling-out. Through all of it, the Will sits in a drawer saying exactly what it said on the day it was signed.

A High Court decision handed down this summer shows what that can mean in practice. In James v James [2026] EWHC 2190 (Ch), a mother’s Will from 1994 left her estate to her two sons. One son died before her. The surviving son said the whole estate was now his. The court disagreed — and the dead son’s half passed to his daughter, the mother’s granddaughter, even though the surviving son said his mother had fallen out with her in later years.

For anyone who owns a family business or a property portfolio, this is a case worth understanding. Not because the law is unusual, but because it shows how a quiet rule most people have never heard of can decide who ends up owning what you have built.

What happened in James v James

Constantia James made her Will on 15 July 1994. Clause 9 left her residuary estate — everything not given away elsewhere in the Will — on trust for her two sons, Mark and Jonathan, “as shall survive me and attain the age of Twenty One years and if more than one in equal shares”. The clause then went on to deal with the sons’ children taking by substitution in certain circumstances.

When the Will was signed, both sons were alive and neither had children. Mark died in September 2017, leaving one child, Olivia. Constantia died in February 2023. Jonathan, who was also the executor, was still living and had children of his own.

The question for the court, decided by Master McQuail on 26 August 2026, was simple to state: did Olivia inherit the half share her father would have taken, or did everything go to Jonathan as the only son who survived?

Jonathan argued that the words “as shall survive me” meant only a surviving son could inherit. He also told the court that his mother and Olivia had fallen out in recent years, so she would not have wanted Olivia to benefit. The solicitors who drafted the Will had kept no file, so there was no record of what Constantia had intended back in 1994.

What the court decided — and why

The answer turned on section 33 of the Wills Act 1837. In plain English, it says this: if your Will leaves something to a child or grandchild of yours, and that person dies before you leaving children who are alive when you die, the gift passes to those children instead — unless your Will shows a contrary intention.

The judge described the approach in earlier cases as “contract out, not contract in”. The rule applies automatically. If you do not want it to apply, your Will has to make that clear.

Master McQuail held that the words “as shall survive me” did not do that. They identified who would take if they were alive at Constantia’s death, but they neither said nor necessarily implied that a dead son’s children should be shut out. The proviso about grandchildren taking by substitution did not help Jonathan either. If anything, it pointed the other way: it showed a mother who had thought about grandchildren inheriting, and it simply said nothing about the situation that actually arose. As the judgment put it, silence is not enough to exclude the rule.

The falling-out made no difference. A Will is read in the light of the circumstances when it was made, not what happened decades later. Clause 9 was signed long before Olivia was born, and its wording had nothing to do with who was on good terms with whom. With no file and no admissible evidence of a different intention, the statutory rule applied and Olivia took her father’s share.

A worked example — purely illustrative

Take a Sussex couple — call them Richard and Helen — who built up a successful engineering company and, alongside it, a handful of rental flats in Worthing and Brighton. Years ago they made Wills leaving everything to each other and then equally to “such of our children as survive us”: their son Tom, who works in the business, and their daughter Kate, who does not.

Kate sadly dies before her parents, leaving two young children. Some years later Richard and Helen die. Tom has always assumed he and his sister’s family would sort things out sensibly. But on the wording of the Wills, section 33 may well mean Kate’s half of the estate — including half of the company shares and half of the flats — passes to her two children.

That may be exactly what Richard and Helen would have wanted. But consider what follows. Two minors cannot run a company or manage tenants. Someone has to hold their inheritance until they come of age, and if the gift is outright, they will be entitled to it at 18. Tom finds himself in business with two young shareholders and whoever is looking after their interests. Decisions about selling a flat, reinvesting profits or bringing in a new director now need agreement from people who may see things very differently.

None of this is anyone’s fault. It is simply what happens when a Will written for one family is applied to a family that has changed.

The traps

Assuming “survive me” means “survivors take all”

It is natural to read “to my children who survive me” as meaning the surviving children share everything. James v James confirms, in line with earlier decisions, that those words alone are generally not enough to stop a predeceased child’s children inheriting.

Relying on what “everyone knows” Mum or Dad wanted

Family understanding, conversations at Sunday lunch and later fallings-out are not the Will. The court looks at the words, read in the setting in which they were written. If your wishes have changed, the place to record that is your Will.

Forgetting the business itself

Company shares do not sit in a vacuum. The company’s articles of association, and any shareholders’ agreement, may contain rules about who can hold shares and what happens when a shareholder dies. If shares pass to a grandchild, those rules come into play. Your Will and your company paperwork need to point in the same direction.

Leaving young beneficiaries with assets they cannot manage

A grandchild inheriting a share of a portfolio or a trading company is a very different thing from a grown-up child inheriting it. Without thought, the result can be an outright inheritance at 18 and a family business held partly for a child.

What to do

  • Decide what you actually want. If one of your children died before you, should their share go to their children, to your other children, or somewhere else? There is no right answer — only your answer.
  • Say it in your Will. Whether you want grandchildren to step into their parent’s shoes or not, a clear provision avoids leaving the decision to a default rule and, potentially, to a court.
  • Think about age and control. If grandchildren may inherit, consider whether their share should be held in trust for longer than 18, and who should manage it — particularly where business shares or rental property are involved.
  • Join up the business side. Make sure your Will, your company’s articles and any shareholders’ agreement work together, so the people running the business are not left in an impossible position.
  • Review when life changes. A death, a birth, a marriage, a divorce, a business sale or a falling-out are all moments to look at your Will again. A Will made in 1994 was always going to be read against the family of 1994.

The short version

James v James is not a dramatic case. There was no fraud, no question of capacity and no dispute that the Will was valid. It was a family trying to work out what a few words meant almost thirty years after they were written. The law gave a clear answer — and it may not have been the answer the surviving son expected.

The lesson for business owners and property investors is straightforward. Your Will speaks for you when you can no longer speak for yourself. It should say what you mean about the people who matter most, including what happens if the unexpected happens first.

If you would like to talk through how your Will deals with your family, your business or your property, book a Discovery Call. It is 30 minutes, the fee is £30, and that is credited against your fees if you go on to instruct us.

Get Legacy Insights free every Sunday

Six short reads each week on tax, Wills, family wealth and running a business, from John Ireland. Since 1996, three decades of protecting families.

Subscribe free

Need to discuss your estate?

Book a free discovery call to learn more about how to protect your assets.


Book a discovery call
Download our FREE Estate
Planning Guide


Client Testimonial

“Having seen John of Legacy Wills present at a property event, it was clear he had both the breadth of knowledge and experience and also the ability to make a very dry subject both understandable and engaging. That’s a tough call when talking about Wills, Trusts and death. John produced Wills and POA’s for myself and my wife in a timely, effective and reasonable manner. I have subsequently recommended him to numerous colleagues and friends to cut out the jargon and challenges surrounding this critical protection, which is too often deferred or neglected.”

Dan Norman